Are you an existing policy holder?

Montgomery judgement is still front-of-mind for insurers and clinicians

It’s over two years since the Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board case changed the process of informed consent between doctor and patient. In October 2016, the Royal College of Surgeons (RCS) issued new guidance[1] for working with patients through the process of informed decision-making.

Although many professionals are becoming accustomed to the new consent process, legal commentators note that it is still very much a “live” issue. One legal and consulting firm predicts a rise in consent claims, suggesting that hospitals and clinicians need to take action to protect themselves. They even report hearing of Montgomery-related allegations being added to existing claims[2]. PMP’s legal advisers Clyde & Co, who won the first case after the Montgomery decision, have suggested that its effects “are yet to be fully worked through”.[3]

However well informed you are about this important legal shift, it’s always good to have access to support when you need it. PMP’s medico-legal helpline is available 24/7 to our policyholders should you ever have specific legal queries.

[1] Consent: Supported Decision-Making – a good practice guide

[2] RPC Annual Insurance Review 2016,, p20

[3] Discussion of alternative treatment options: it’s not optional, Clyde & Co,

Subscribe to our marketing list!